Image Source: Marvel Digital Comics
After Fox’s last stand with Dark Phoenix, Disney will likely look to get their own version of the X-Men in the MCU — here’s a helping hand.
Technically, New Mutants will close the book on Fox’s X-Men franchise. But let’s be real, no one knows if or when it’s going to get released. Plus, New Mutants has a completely different cast of characters. This is all about the dawn of the X-Men, which started nearly two decades ago. That’s why Dark Phoenix gets the curtain call treatment.
What started with Bryan Singer during the dawn of Y2K will end with director Simon Kinberg. With his team of writers, Ashley Miller, Jane Goldman, and Zack Stentz, he fixed Fox’s original debacle. X-Men: First Class was, at the time, one of the greatest comic book movies ever.
First Class reintroduced some X-Men characters in a prequel that rebooted the franchise. The cast, led by James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Nicholas Hoult, and Jennifer Lawrence, did an amazing job. However, based on the poor reviews for Dark Phoenix, rebooting the franchise is inevitable.
How Disney plans to introduce the X-Men into the MCU is anyone’s guess. What age range will they opt for? Will there be an origin story? But no matter which direction they take, there are several arcs and characters waiting for adaptation.
For reasons unknown, Fox couldn’t capitalize on some great characters and stories. Characters like Emma Frost and Gambit were wasted. While stories like the “Mutant Massacre” didn’t get told. And the telling of the Morlocks vs. the X-Men missed its mark. There was hope with this new cast, but that’s not happening.
More from Marvel Cinematic Universe
- Loki season 2 finale does set the stage for Kang Dynasty
- Marvel: (Spoiler) exits Avengers: The Kang Dynasty
- Will Loki air a new bonus episode tonight? (November 16, 2023)
- What If…? season 2 gets premiere date (and there’s a major twist)
- Marvel rumors hint Pedro Pascal has been cast in key Fantastic Four role
Who Disney cast ultimately depends on what story they want to tell. For some roles, casting actors who are in their mid to late 20s gives them flexibility. And adding actors who aren’t particularly known relieves some pressure.
Hopefully, Disney draws inspiration from the 90s X-Men cartoon, which is arguably the best version of Marvel’s mutants. Disney has done exceptionally well when it comes to casting, so fans shouldn’t worry. With that said, everyone needs a little nudge in the right direction starting with the big bad(s).
LOS ANGELES, CA – JANUARY 25: Actor Rory McCann attends the 21st Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards at The Shrine Auditorium on January 25, 2015 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
Rory McCann as Juggernaut
Whether you’re a fan of the comics or a casual X-Men fan, many agree that Juggernaut was one of many mutants neglected by Fox. He wasn’t invisible, just forgettable. Well, it’s hard to forget how terrible he was in X-Men: The Last Stand. Besides not having any palpable relationship with the X-Men or Professor X. He was relegated to a supporting role where he was made to look like a dufus. At least he made Shadowcat cool.
It was actor Vinnie Jones who played the role, and his character deserved better. Ryan Reynolds did that in Deadpool 2. In a comedic way, Juggernaut’s relationship with Professor X was discussed. Still, he was nothing more than a side character, albeit vastly improved.
Now that the Fox franchise is over, there’s a chance for Disney to capitalize n a villain who has an important connection with the X-Men and the Marvel Universe. Juggernaut has a story that’s worth telling in a film where he’s the primary villain. His character isn’t just a one-off villain either, thanks to him eventually joining the Avengers.
In some ways, Rory McCann’s Game of Thrones character is like Juggernaut. There’s a dark, checkered past with his brother. He’s hardcore, but does have a soft spot that makes you root for him. At six feet, six inches tall, McCann has the height and look needed for Juggernaut.
CANNES, FRANCE – MAY 27: Eva Green attends the “Based On A True Story” screening during the 70th annual Cannes Film Festival at Palais des Festivals on May 27, 2017 in Cannes, France. (Photo by Antony Jones/Getty Images)
Eva Green as Callisto
One of the more iconic arcs in the X-Men comics featured the Warlocks. Their underground hideout was a home for mutants who didn’t look like the X-Men. They are the result of Dark Beast and were forced to live in the sewers.
Their leader was Callisto, the tough as nails mutant skilled in hand-to-hand combat. The Morlocks kidnapped and tortured what they called “surface dwellers.” One of their victims was Angel, whom she kidnapped and debilitated by cutting off his feathers.
The aforementioned events led to a rescue mission led by, Strom who battled Callisto for supremacy. In X-Men: The Last Stand, Fox patronized fans. They allowed Storm and Callisto to battle, but there was nothing on the line. It was a one-off fight that lacked storytelling.
Consequently, Callisto became nothing more than a distant memory in a movie that did nothing for fans. Disney has a great opportunity on their hands. X-Men v. The Morlocks is a story that can lead to something more. It has the potential to carry most of a movie that connects to a larger arc, “The Mutant Massacre.”
Eva Green is an immensely talented actress that can take Callisto to great heights — even in a one-off story.
NEW YORK, NY – JANUARY 11: Bryan Cranston attends The American Associates Of The National Theatre Celebrate “Network” at The Rainbow Room on January 11, 2019 in New York City. (Photo by Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images)
Bryan Cranston as Mister Sinister
Nathaniel Essex aka Mister Sinister, leads a group of mutants known as The Marauders. With Gambit at the helm he sends the group into New York to murder the underground mutants, the Morlocks. The tragic arc is known as the Mutant Massacre in the pages of Marvel Comics.
When it’s all said and done, the Mutant Massacre is an arc that the fans deserve — Feige should give it to us. Sinister is the mastermind that follows Apocalypse with hatred for the Summers family and the X-Men.
When the day comes that the Stan Lee biopic gets the green light, Bryan Cranston should be the one to get the call. But before that happens, Kevin Feige and Disney should do what needs to be done by casting Cranston as Mister Sinister.
Moreover, he’s had an impact on the X-Men Universe like few others. Cranston is well aware of this, which is why he’s talked about the possibility of playing Sinister.
"“I want to play an antagonist a fraction smarter than the protagonist, never dumbed down to give the hero an easy win… Mister Sinister was the character I was thinking about. I guess it’s a selfish standpoint. I don’t want to do a character that has been done several times before”"
We’ve seen Cranston play several roles. Whether it’s the desperate father turned drug dealer in Breaking Bad. Or the big bad in the Total Recall remake. There’s no limit to what Cranston can do.
LONDON, ENGLAND – JULY 16: Jeremy Irvine attends the “Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again” world premiere at the Eventim Apollo, Hammersmith on July 16, 2018 in London, England. (Photo by Eamonn M. McCormack/Getty Images for Universal Pictures )
Jeremy Irvine as Gambit
Does anyone remember seeing Gambit in Fox’s X-Men universe? Taylor Kitsch was the first to play the smooth-talking, card throwing mutant in X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
Sadly, it wasn’t a good or memorable outing for Kitsch or Gambit. Kitsch never stood a chance in a movie that divided fans and was panned by critics. Unfortunately, we didn’t see Gambit again.
For years, fans thought Fox, with the help of Channing Tatum, would produce a Gambit solo film. That never happened and likely won’t, at least not yet. Gambit’s backstory has major implications, so a solo movie or series makes sense, even for Disney.
If Gambit does happen, the movie must include Sinister who has been teased in Fox’s X-Men movies, specifically Deadpool. Having Gambit lead the Marauders in a movie that ultimately connects to a larger arc fits what Disney does best.
As comic fans know, the larger arc is the “Mutant Massacre.” We have our Mister Sinister in Bryan Cranston, that was easy. But Gambit was difficult. Channing Tatum, while committed, is too old for the role among a cast of young adults.
In a world where Hugh Jackman is Wolverine and James Madsen is Cyclops, Tatum would work. But with Disney, they need an up-and-coming actor who can play in movie as dramatic like Gambit.
Most people won’t know the name Jeremy Irvine, who got his claim to fame in War Horse. His roles are mostly dramatic, and it’s those performances that allude to his ability to play Gambit. Irvine also starred in the Mamma Mia! sequel, and is set to shine in a movie starring Samuel Jackson, The Last Full Measure.
LOS ANGELES, CA – JANUARY 04: Actor Emily Blunt attends the 19th Annual AFI Awards at Four Seasons Hotel Los Angeles at Beverly Hills on January 4, 2019 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images)
Emily Blunt as Mystique
The original X-Men Trilogy disrespected Mystique’s greatness. At least Jennifer Lawrence’s version of Mystique had a great story. However, the best parts about her were left out, so she needs a reboot, maybe even a movie or series of her own — here’s why.
Throughout history, Mystique went by many names and each one with a different story. In the 20s, a young Wolverine joined her pickpocket gang; she would eventually toss his from a train. One of her identities, Leni Zauber, was a detective who ended up mothering a child with Sabretooth.
That child would grow up the mutant-hating human, Graydon Creed, whom she had to kill. As Raven Darkholme, she married a wealthy man, cheated on him and mothered a child with Azazel, Nightcrawler. She was forced to abandon him as a newborn and fled the village.
After she met Destiny, they would adopt and raise Rogue. She also worked for the U.S. as Deputy Director of the Defense Advanced Research Planning Agency. She used the program to fund her terrorist ways including the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants.
This all leads to one epic battle where her team defeated the Avengers after Rogue absorbs Captain Marvel’s powers. Emily Blunt (A Quiet Place) is the actress to play her.
After the many teases, Blunt can finally take part in a comic book movie. She’s talented enough to bring out the best parts of Mystique.
LAS VEGAS, NV – JUNE 21: Host Joe Manganiello attends the 2017 NHL Awards at T-Mobile Arena on June 21, 2017 in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)
Joe Manganiello as Sabretooth
Once Kevin Feige gets his hands on the X-Men, you can bet Sabretooth will make his MCU debut. While he’s primarily a Wolverine villain, he can work as secondary big bad. Sticking with the Mutant Massacre, Sabretooth is one of Sinister’s followers.
Plus, there’s a time in history where he’s part of the special ops group with Wolverine and Omega Red, which works well as a series. The man to play the role, of course, is Joe Manganiello.
Here’s the thing, there’s no way Warner Bros and Walter Hamada should allow Manganiello to not play Deathstroke. With that said, playing two comic book characters isn’t a bad idea.
Manganiello has everything needed to play Sabretooth, including the rugged looks, massive build, and necessary charisma to warrant intrigue. The last time we saw Sabretooth was in X-Men Origins: Wolverine played by Liev Schreiber.
We aren’t looking for a Fox Victor Creed repeat. No, this version should be the pure animalistic murdering psychopath, Sabretooth, with full makeup and a look that’s ripped straight from the comics.
"“Victor Creed is the feral mutant called Sabretooth. He was a member/subject of the Weapon X Project and is the arch-enemy of Wolverine… Unlike Wolverine, Sabretooth embraces his primal instincts, leaving death in his wake.”"
The MCU could opt to invoke the Scarlet Witch that made Sabretooth a good guy. Then Manganiello can play the more heroic version of the hero as well. In fact, that version would work well in the inevitable “X-Men v Avengers” arc we’ll likely see in the MCU. Until then, he would make for an excellent one-off big bad.
NEW YORK, NY – APRIL 21: Blake Lively attends Variety’s Power Of Women: New York at Cipriani Midtown on April 21, 2017 in New York City. (Photo by Mike Coppola/Getty Images)
Blake Lively as Emma Frost
It’s a shame how they treated Emma Frost in the X-Men movie universe. In the first trilogy, she wasn’t used at all. Singer cast her aside like some supporting character.
After years of nothingness, we got what we wanted in X-Men: First Class, but she died. It was disappointing, considering how well January Jones portrayed her. Despite how she was written in the comics, she was the forgotten member of the X-Men in the sole movie she was part of.
Emma is renowned for her beauty, intellect, and psychic ability in the comics. Another missing aspect of her past was her relationship with Cyclops. However, Emma is more than eye candy.
While she has some devious ways, she has good in her. As depicted accurately in the movies, she was a member of the Hellfire Club. But what we didn’t see was her turning over a new leaf and becoming a valued member of the X-Men.
As one of the more powerful psychics in the comics, Emma deserves better. Emma Frost seems like a character who would benefit from some star power. Blake Lively has that in spades.
Over the years, she’s nailed every role she had. Movies like Savages, Age of Adeline Shallows, and A Simple Favor proved she’s a leading lady. Expect nothing less from the upcoming revenge flick, Rhythm Section.
If Disney wants to distance themselves from Fox’s X-Men, putting her in the right era helps. She needs to be part of the X-Men that features Professor X’s original team. Too much of her story is tied to them.
HOLLYWOOD, CA – OCTOBER 08: Michiel Huisman attends the premiere of Netflix’s “The Haunting Of Hill House” at ArcLight Hollywood on October 8, 2018, in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images)
Michiel Huisman as Mastermind
The Mutant Master Illusionist Mastermind was nowhere to be found in the Fox franchise. He was one of the mutants forgotten by Fox but shouldn’t be with Disney. It’s a shame that Fox didn’t carve out more time for “The Dark Phoenix Saga.”
If they had, we would have seen Mastermind and gotten a better story. Neither Last Stand nor Dark Phoenix depicted the other side of the Phoenix Saga. The story where he manipulated Jean into marrying him.
Mastermind is also part of the original Brotherhood of Evil Mutants formed by Magneto. He battles the X-Men and even forms his own version of the group.
The X-Men v the Brotherhood is a classic story we haven’t seen told in live-action. Mastermind would make a solid supporting character with major ramifications for the team.
There’s enough vagueness in his comic book history to allow them to tell whatever story they want. Mastermind is a character that Disney can use, and it will feel fresh.
Michiel Huisman is known as the oldest Crane in Haunted Hill House and as Daario Naharis Game of Thrones. Huisman also starred alongside Blake Lively in The Age of Adeline. Because of his acting prowess, he would make Mastermind a masterpiece.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK – APRIL 08: Actress Margaret Qualley attends FX’s “Fosse/Verdon” New York Premiere on April 08, 2019 in New York City. (Photo by Mike Coppola/Getty Images)
Margaret Qualley as Rogue
Rogue means more to the Marvel Universe than previously depicted in the X-Men. The talented Anna Paquin did a great job in the role given to her. Of course, Fox didn’t have the rights to Captain Marvel, so the super powered version of Rogue didn’t happen.
Still, the essence of her character was watered down. There wasn’t that endless devotion to her mother, Mystique. Her inner battle between bad good was completely left out and replaced by the inner struggle of being a mutant or not.
Rogue is undoubtedly going to get the reboot treatment, but that doesn’t mean going back to the ’90s version. Christos Gage and artist David Baldeon’s version works best for the MCU. They’ll need a young actress with an unassuming yet tough girl look. Someone who can capture the emotional side Rogue, but also the charming, joking sarcastic side.
Then there’s the post-Captain Marvel absorption. She’s more heroic and part of Captain Marvel exists in her. None of that happens until after she goes temporarily insane. The battles between Rogue and Captain Marvel are entertaining. Rogue’s a layered character who will thrive in the MCU.
With that said, former The Leftovers star Margaret Qualley can pull it off. Warner Bros allegedly considered the 5-8 actress for the role of Huntress in Birds of Prey. Her resume includes Netflix’s live-action Death Note as the sociopath Mia Sutton.
Most recently she starred in the HBO adaptation of Richard Wright’s novel Native Son as Mary. Qualley’s set to star alongside Brad Pitt, Margot Robbie, and Leonardo DiCaprio in Once Upon a Time.
Rogue, Destiny, and Mystique could star in their own Disney Plus miniseries. This would give them a chance to introduce fans to Rogue before giving fans a Captain Marvel v Rogue movie.
LONDON, ENGLAND – FEBRUARY 10: Joe Alwyn attends the EE British Academy Film Awards at Royal Albert Hall on February 10, 2019 in London, England. (Photo by Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images)
Joe Alwyn as Quicksilver
Will the real Quicksilver please stand up? Between Disney’s MCU and Fox’s X-Men franchise, we’ve seen two versions of the silver-haired mutant. There’s Aaron Taylor Johnson, who played Pietro, (not Quicksilver) in Age of Ultron, debuting with Wanda (Elizabeth Olson).
Like the comics, Pietro fought alongside the Avengers, but he would never get the chance to get called Quicksilver. Disney had their hands tied since they didn’t own the rights to the X-Men characters. So there was no relation or mention of Magneto or the term “mutant.” Instead, they had his history tied to HYDRA.
Thanks to Fox and Evan Peter,s Quicksilver burst onto the scene in X-Men: Days of Future Past in epic fashion. Peters’ version of the hero was different from its MCU counterpart. He was young, vibrant, and comedic.
In a perfect world, we would have gotten to see Johnson sign that multi-film contract and return so that his character can become the mutant who teetered between bad and good and ultimately, joining the Avengers to atone for his sins. And of course, challenge Hawkeye for the leadership of the Avengers.
In case that doesn’t happen, it’s time to look forward to a third Quicksilver. This version should feel like the comic book version, a combination of Johnson and Peters.
This also means being Magneto’s son and a member of The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. He would also possibly give him his life in Attilan, where he would live after Wanda resurrects him. Admittedly, the last part is ambitious, but you get the point.
Joe Alwyn isn’t a household name, yet, but the 28-year-old actor is slowly making a name for himself. His most recent films, Mary Queen of Scots and Fighting with My Family gave more fans a glimpse at what he’s capable of.
BEVERLY HILLS, CA – JANUARY 22: Actor Stephen Lang speaks onstage during the 22nd Annual Producers Guild Awards at The Beverly Hilton hotel on January 22, 2011 in Beverly Hills, California. (Photo by Kevin Winter/Getty Images for Producers Guild)
Stephen Lang as Magneto
There’s no replicating or replacing what Michael Fassbender did for Magneto. He gave us a dramatic depiction of an antivillain who has mega fanfare. It’s hard to imagine any other actor playing the younger version of Sir Ian McKellen’s Magneto. That’s over with, and it is time to move forward.
When it came to human/mutant relations, he took a Malcolm X approach to Professor X’s Martin Luther King. Magneto is aggressive and strong, instilling fear in those who stand against him. The original films exploited Magneto and told his story exceptionally well.
Now, it’s time for something a little different. Aside from the intellect that Magneto possessed, his intimidating look equated his raw power. He was the leader of the original Brotherhood of Evil Mutants.
We don’t need another story where Magneto is pseudo working alongside the X-Men. That’ll happen in time. Right now, we need an intimidating, militant revolutionist. We want Magneto, the leader of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, alongside his son (Quicksilver) and daughter (Scarlet Witch).
Stephen Lang can bring a different type of intensity to Magneto, one that makes him feel like a true villain. Based on looks alone, Lang has the intimidation factor. It’s why so many fans wanted him to play Cable before Josh Brolin got the role.
If you want to know what he’ll bring to Magneto, watch him in Avatar and Don’t Breathe. Magneto doesn’t need to be part of every film. On the contrary, his appearance should feel powerful.
SEOUL, SOUTH KOREA – SEPTEMBER 21: Mark Strong attends the ‘Kingsman: The Golden Circle’ press conference at Yongsan CGV on September 21, 2017 in Seoul, South Korea. (Photo by Han Myung-Gu/Getty Images)
Mark Strong as Professor X
To say James McAvoy and Patrick Stewart performed miraculously isn’t an overstatement, but, they aren’t coming back. Mark Strong as Professor X is as old as the age of fan cast time, and understandably so.
Strong exudes what fans look for in a comic accurate Professor Charles Xavier. On looks alone, he has it in the bag. He brings an intense look that we haven’t seen from McAvoy or Stewart.
Of course, looks aren’t everything, and his resume is littered with examples of his greatness. From Kingsman, to Merlin to The Brothers Grimsby, he’s done it all. And it doesn’t hurt that he’s no stranger to comic book movies.
Although Green Lantern didn’t go over well, Mark Strong made an impression on fans as Sinestro. Apparently, he made an impact on Warner Bros, as they decided to bring him back, this time as the villain for Shazam. As expected, Strong lived up to the role of Doctor Sivana.
By the time the X-Men are introduced into the MCU, his role in the Shazam sequel as Doctor Sivana will be up. Introduce Strong into the MCU as Professor X and allow him to put his own stamp of the leader of the X-Men.
Professor X doesn’t need to be featured heavily. There are arcs where he’s left out one way or another. Disney has the opportunity to put the spotlight on the team of X-Men instead of Professor X.
VENICE, ITALY – SEPTEMBER 11: Actor Alexander Ludwig attends a photocall for ‘Go With Me’ during the 72nd Venice Film Festival at Palazzo del Casino on September 11, 2015 in Venice, Italy. (Photo by Ernesto Ruscio/Getty Images)
Alexander Ludwig as Beast
Nicholas Hoult was a beast in the X-Men trilogy, taking the reins from Kelsey Grammer. Both actors did an amazing job as Henry “Hank” McCoy. Fox told a great story about one of the original X-Men. Hoult and Grammer brought a theatrical and dramatic feel to their characters. And trying to replicate that version of Beast would be difficult, but not impossible.
Telling a comic accurate story of Hank will help. Causal fans might not have known the comic book version of Hank was an athletically gifted genius who wasn’t shy about it. Unlike Hoult’s character, who needed Mystique to help him with his swag.
Another thing that Disney can fix is Beast being part of the original X-Men. Hank was part of the original five X-Men that included Jean, Scott, and Bobby.
For this version of Beast, Disney needs an actor who looks athletic, but can play a genius. Vikings actor Alexander Ludwig can do just that. He doesn’t just have the brutish look, but he’s capable of dramatic performances and turning on the charm.
It also doesn’t hurt that he’s no stranger to the big screen. He stared in The Final Girls, Final Girl, Blackway and several other films. His star is growing, and he’s set to star alongside Will Smith and Martin Lawrence in Bad Boys For Life.
LOS ANGELES, CA – MARCH 23: Peyton Elizabeth Lee attends Nickelodeon’s 2019 Kids’ Choice Awards at Galen Center on March 23, 2019 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images)
Peyton Elizabeth Lee as Jubilee
It’s a shame we didn’t get the amazing mall scene that featured Landa Condor’s interpretation of the character. Even more disappointing is that Condor didn’t return for Dark Phoenix. Jubilee and Condor were wasted in Apocalypse. Although, Condor has found success after her performance in the role.
Jubilee needs a reboot form Disney, since Fox did nothing for her. In the ’90s, Marvel opted to give Wolverine a sidekick. Guess who that was? Jubilee. A solid source for some Jubilee material is Fox’s animated series.
The pilot episode saw her foster parents rat her out to mutant control. While on the run, she ran into Storm and Rogue before ultimately being saved and brought to the Mansion. Like the comics, she shared a uniquebond with Wolverine.
In the comics, Jubilee helps Wolverine by nursing him back to health. This happened after he was crucified by the Reavers, which honestly sounds like it would make for a great miniseries.
Andi Mack star Peyton Elizabeth Lee fits the bill. She’s 15 and looks like Jubilee ripped from the comics. In fact, rumors suggested Lee was at one point considered for the role of Cassandra Cain in Birds of Prey. She’s not Cassandra Cain, but she could be an amazing Jubilee.
LONDON, ENGLAND – FEBRUARY 10: Timothée Chalamet attends the EE British Academy Film Awards at Royal Albert Hall on February 10, 2019 in London, England. (Photo by Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images)
Timothée Chalamet as Nightcrawler
One of the more underused characters in the X-Men movie franchise was Nightcrawler. In X-Men (2000), Alan Cumming played Nightcrawler, where he had an amazing opening scene. He was brainwashed into killing the president. However, he eventually helped our heroes but faded into obscurity.
We wouldn’t see Nightcrawler again until X-Men: Apocalypse. Bryan Singer did bring Nightcrawler back, with Kodi Smit-McPhee playing the role of Kurt Wagner. Once again, Nightcrawler shined, taking on Angel in another amazing scene.
Still, there hasn’t been much attention paid to who he was. Fans of the teleporting, warm-hearted mutant recognize that Kurt has more depth than previously depicted. Nightcrawler is a character in desperate need of a reboot.
For example, there wasn’t much attention paid to him being the son of Mystique and (non-biological) brother to Rogue. There wasn’t a story that detailed his journey to Germany where he was forced to take down his child-murdering brother.
Like so many other characters his story would work well in as Disney Plus miniseries or movie on the streaming service. And it’s Timothée Chalamet, who could pull off the blue-furred devout Catholic.
Chalamet played young Tim in Interstellar before going on to establish himself as future Oscar nominee in Call Me By Your Name, Lady Bird, and Beautiful Boy. He’s an immensely talented actor who would make Nightcrawler feel like more than a supporting character.
CULVER CITY, CA – JANUARY 26: Honoree Liam Hemsworth attends the 2019 G’Day USA Gala at 3LABS on January 26, 2019 in Culver City, California. (Photo by John Sciulli/Getty Images for G’Day USA )
Liam Hemsworth as Angel
We saw Angel depicted in the previous X-Men franchise, where he was first played by Ben Foster in X-Men: The Last Stand. Foster did a great job for a role that yearned for more. Unfortunately, in X-Men: Apocalypse, actor Ben Hardy didn’t get the proper treatment, either.
In the comics, Angel was manipulated by Apocalypse who restored his wings, at a cost. Needless to say, he was more than a brainwashed henchman to the god-like mutant. In the pages of Marvel comics, he was one of the original X-Men.
Moreover, prior to becoming a member of the X-Men, Warren Worthington III emerged as a superhero after discovering he could fly. It wasn’t until running into Iceman and Cyclops that he became an X-Men.
Even after departing from the X-Men, Angel continued his heroics as part of the Champions and the Defenders. Another mark missed by the original series was Angel’s brash personality, and Liam Hemsworth can capture that.
This may come off a bit cheesy to some since his brother (Chris Hemsworth) plays Thor, but little brother Liam Hemsworth is made for a comic book movie role, and Angel is the ideal role for him.
After showing potential in Independence Day: Resurgence and The Duel, he would get a chance to star in comic book movie. Let’s face he, he looks like a comic book hero already. Hemsworth will have an opportunity to play a version of Angel we haven’t seen.
HOLLYWOOD, CALIFORNIA – JUNE 07: Joey King attends Hulu’s “The Act” FYC event at Linwood Dunn Theater at the Pickford Center for Motion Study on June 07, 2019 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Erik Voake/Getty Images for Hulu)
Joey King as Shadowcat
Who doesn’t love Kitty Pryde aka Shadowcat? She’s an underrated and undervalued member of the X-Men team in the movie franchise. She played a major role in a battle between the X-Men and Hellfire Club. You couldn’t tell by watching any of the X-Men movies.
Also, fans of the comics know that it was Kitty, not Wolverine who played a major role in the “Days of Future Past” arc. Ellen Page’s portrayal as Kitty garnered fan support; with hopes of a solo movie included. The Disney/Fox merger may phase out any plans for the Kitty Pryde solo film, though.
Fans can finally see Shadowcat and her alien dragon-like pet, Lockheed. It’s a perfect Disney miniseries, The Adventures of Shadowcat and Lockheed, which can also introduce Colossus. But before that happens, Kitty needs her story told correctly.
Kitty started off as a little sister character, who developed a relationship with Colossus. One of her greatest arcs features Doctor Doom and the Fantastic Four. She would eventually branch off and form her own group with Nightcrawler known as Excalibur, before becoming the headmistress at Jean Grey’s School for Higher Learning.
A young actress who can play a teen before growing into the role as a young adult makes sense. Joey King is 19, but has proven that she’s a transformative actress. If you want proof, catch her in The Act. See what I did there.
HOLLYWOOD, CALIFORNIA – DECEMBER 09: Dylan O’Brien attends the premiere of Paramount Pictures’ “Bumblebee” at TCL Chinese Theatre on December 09, 2018 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by David Livingston/Getty Images)
Dylan O’Brien as Iceman
To put it mildly, Fox gave Iceman the cold shoulder. We get it, they needed to cram as many X-Men into the original franchise as possible. Unfortunately, it was at the risk of a character that fans of the X-Men comics love. Iceman has a following large enough to warrant Marvel developing a solo comic run.
Arguably the most disappointing arc in the entire X-Men series was Iceman, Bobby Drake. It’s not to say he wasn’t used, because he was. But he wasn’t used the correct way. For starters, he wasn’t a member of the X-Men that joined with Rogue.
Part of what makes him great is his energetic and somewhat rebellious personality. The Bryan Singer Bobby wasn’t that at all. He was a glorified love interest for Rogue, and Iceman deserves more.
As a matter of fact, Disney Plus could capitalize on Iceman and Angel’s UCLA days. Imagine a comedy with two mutants in college, “Iceman and Angel: The Dorm Days.”
Who better to put some respect on Iceman’s name than Dylan O’Brien. He’s already held down a successful franchise with The Maze Runner. Plus, he’s shown he can kick butt in American Assassin.
LOS ANGELES, CA – OCTOBER 19: Tati Gabrielle attends Netflix Original Series “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina” red carpet and premiere event on October 19, 2018 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Rachel Murray/Getty Images for Netflix)
Tati Gabrielle as Storm
Despite amazing performances by Halle Berry and Alexandra Shipp, Storm’s character feels incomplete. We aren’t talking about including the terrible Black Panther romance, either.
The African-born Ororo Munroe is part of a royal bloodline. In every generation, a person is born with white hair and blue eyes. Their power is inherited, usually from mother to daughter.
South of an Omega Level mutant, Storm is one of the strongest mutants in Marvel Comics. Storm offers a history worthy of a miniseries. Disney Plus, we’re looking at you. Besides her independent history, Storm is one of the more pivotal members of the X-Men.
One of the best comic book arcs saw her become the leader of the Morlocks after she defeated Callisto. Fox’s animated series did a great job playing out the epic battle. With Disney likely recasting, Tati Gabrielle is the perfect actress to take on the role.
Of course, she’s unknown, much like Shipp was before taking the role. Her The 100, character Gaia is similar to Storm in her nurturing ways, strength and ability to lead. And on Netflix’s Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina she’s the complete opposite.
As Prudence, she’s nasty, mean, daring, sensual but still displays courage and tenacity. She looks the part and has the potential to nail the role in Disney’s MCU. We would like to see Storm in a miniseries where Forge is introduced.
MADRID, SPAIN – MAY 18: Actor Jack O’Connell attends ‘Money Monster’ premiere at Picasso Tower roof on May 18, 2016 in Madrid, Spain. (Photo by Pablo Cuadra/Getty Images)
Jack O’Connell as Wolverine
There’s nothing more to say about Wolverine. Hugh Jackman ended his run with an amazing performance in Logan. If there’s any X-Man that got enough attention, it was Wolverine.
Fox gave him the royal treatment. Jackman starred in three solo movies. And he was given the time traveling arc that belonged to Kitty in Days of Future Past. Still, he’s become the face of the X-Men, so he’ll have to get recast.
Unlike the times past, Wolverine shouldn’t be the focal point of the X-Men. He’s overwhelmingly popular, but it’s time to let some other members of the team shine.
For a long time, before Venom, any name that wasn’t Tom Hardy was going to get shot down. But this guy, Jack O’Connell, exudes all the qualities of a potential Wolverine.
For starters, he has the rugged look and a comic book accurate build. Even more important, his resume is filled with examples of his acting prowess. If you haven’t seen him act, then you’re missing out.
Skins was where he got his start but, since then, he’s been cranking out great performances, like a desperate man wronged by Wall Street in Money Monster or starring in a drama like The Man with the Iron Heart. His most critically acclaimed role came in 2013’s Starred Up.
Warner Bros. allegedly had their eyes on him for The Batman. Since that’s not happening, Disney can use him. All they have to do his lace him with adamantium, suit him up, and call him Logan.
NEW YORK, NY – DECEMBER 18: Hailee Steinfeld visits Build on December 18, 2018 at Build Studio in New York City. (Photo by Nicholas Hunt/Getty Images)
Hailee Steinfeld as Jean Grey
Fox didn’t do a horrible job with Jean, although Dark Phoenix messed up the continuity that was allegedly established, despite the reboot. It’s confusing to us, too. Simply put, we’ve seen the Phoenix Saga play out twice.
So fans of the X-Men movies were given an in-depth version of the comic book character. It’s established that Jean is a dangerous foe once the Phoenix Force takes over. It’s an emotional arc that still hasn’t been told with all the pieces in place, unfortunately.
Since we see it play out twice, the arc will likely not get told again. In the original, Jean was played by Famke Janssen, and Sophie Turner played the younger version in Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix. Both women looked the part and performed well, considering the material they were given.
In the MCU, Jean can start fresh and allow her story to unfold slowly. Dark Phoenix is an amazing arc, but Jean has more to offer. For example, after the Z’Nox invasion, she led the X-Men during Xavier’s absence.
Earlier you read that actors in their mid-late 20s makes sense. There’s always an exception to the rules, right? Well, an Oscar-nominated actress is an exception. Bumblebee actress Hailee Steinfeld can make Jean feel larger than life, even if she isn’t the focal point.
Steinfeld is a powerful presence with the skills to tap into the depths of Jean Grey. There’s a complex nature about Jean that hasn’t got the attention it deserves, and they likely won’t make that same mistake.
SANTA MONICA, CA – JUNE 16: Actor Dacre Montgomery attends the 2018 MTV Movie And TV Awards at Barker Hangar on June 16, 2018 in Santa Monica, California. (Photo by Christopher Polk/Getty Images for MTV)
Dacre Montgomery as Cyclops
Cyclops was vastly mistreated in the X-Men movie franchise. This man is the leader of the X-Men, he’s confident and has his own vision. He’s not the boy scout he once was, nor is he Professor X’s lackey. That’s the version of Cyclops we need in the MCU after his previous neglection.
The best example of a misdirected character was none other than Cyclops. Yes, the “leader” of the X-Men. In Age of Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix, Tye Sheridan took over the role as the leader who often gets overshadowed.
Playing the younger version of James Marsden’s Cyclops. To no fault of Marsden, Cyclops was forgettable because the writers forgot how great he was. In The Last Stand, he got an unceremonious death bat the hands of Jean. Sadly, Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix didn’t do him any favors, either.
Thankfully, Disney can ride in on their white horse and save the day. Cyclops needs to the spotlight, and Dacre Montgomery can help give it to him.
He’s begging for a superhero role. Okay, technically he was one, playing Jason in the 2017 Power Rangers movie. Fans also know him from Stranger Things as the bully (and apparent racist) Billy Hargrove. He’s capable of bringing out the best parts of Scott Summers.