Star Trek: All 4 Captain Pike actors ranked from worst to best

1. Anson Mount

Appeared in:  Star Trek: Discovery, Short Treks, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds

Anson Mount’s Pike is

absolutely dreamy

a breath of fresh air in the ever-expanding Star Trek universe.

In a series filled with complex characters and storylines, Mount’s portrayal stands out, effortlessly blending the old-world charisma of the original series with the distinct storytelling of today. He brought a refined balance of leadership, vulnerability, and moral clarity, giving us long-time Trekkies a dose of sweet nostalgia for while also offering something new and engaging for the younger audience. Pike’s return in Star Trek: Discovery wasn’t just a cameo – it was an really well-done character revival, and much of the credit goes to Mount’s understanding and portrayal of Pike.

With Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, Paramount+ took a calculated leap of faith with a series that revolves around Mount’s Captain Pike and his adventures. And it’s not hard to see why. Anson’s Pike gives off a warmth and wisdom that feels both comforting and inspiring. Mount’s Pike reminds us of the foundational principles of Starfleet. As the captain of the Enterprise, prior to Kirk, he sets a tone and standard that resonates with both new and old fans, keeping Captain Pike an integral part of the Star Trek legacy.

And he also has the best hair out of anyone in Star Trek.

Which iteration of Captain Pike is your favorite in the Star Wars lore? Are you a fan of Strange New Worlds?