The best 13 Battlestar Galactica episodes (and the 3 worst ones)

10. “Colonial Day” (Season 1, Episode 11)

Throughout the show, the Battlestar Galactica and its fleet journey in search of the mythical Earth while still holding onto the traditions that bind them. “Colonial Day” is more than just an episode – it’s the celebration of democracy and what it stands for even in the face of possible extinction.

The fleet gathers with very mixed feelings, rightfully so, as they welcome the Quorum of Twelve – the representatives of each of the Twelve Colonies. It shows us that humanity’s need for representation and a voice refuses to be silenced, even in the void of space, while being chased by Cylons and possibly not making it to a new home planet or keep our species from going extinct.

This episode shows the contrast and similarities between politics and personalities. Characters we’ve grown to love and some we’re still “meh” about at this point step into the spotlight, showing everyone what they’re truly made of and their beliefs. As the folks celebrate, form alliances, and raise eyebrows, we’re given a front-row seat to witnessing democracy at its finest in action.

“Colonial Day” is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit – even when faced with the unknown abyss of space, the need for community, governance, and the shared hope of a brighter future remains crucial to our survival as a species.

9. “Scar” (Season 2, Episode 15)

In “Scar,” viewers get a unique twist in the Battlestar Galactica saga. Instead of focusing on the humans, this episode redirects us into the “mind” of a Cylon Raider named Scar.

This isn’t just any raider. Scar is a crafty and relentless Cylon, and has become a real threat for the human fighter pilots. Every time our pilots step out into space, Scar is there and ready to engage, and each encounter shows us more and more about the ongoing conflict between man and machine.

What makes this episode such a good one is that it takes a Cylon – an inorganic entity supposed to be devoid of emotions and personality – and it humanizes it by giving it a persona. Scar isn’t just another enemy to shoot down – he reminds us of the persistent threat looming over the fleet, of the countless battles fought, and of the price everyone pays in wartime. We’re reminded of the larger issue and the bigger picture being chased, and the determination required to keep moving forward.