Skip to main content

Is Selina Kyle in The Batman Part II? Why her absence might be a clever distraction

ByMehwish Mahmood
Zoë Kravitz and Robert Pattinson in The Batman.
Zoë Kravitz and Robert Pattinson in The Batman. | Jonathan Olley/DC Comics

After years of waiting and speculation, filming is only weeks away from wrapping on Matt Reeves' The Batman: Part II. The sequel carries even more anticipation because Pattinson has become one of the most prominent and coveted stars in recent times. While most of the cast for Part II was confirmed, including new and returning names, a notable absence is Zoe Kravitz, who played Catwoman, or Selina Kyle, in Part I.

Pattinson and Kravitz had good chemistry in Part I with a lot of potential for greatness, but currently, most Catwoman fans don't feel positive about her return in the sequel. However, her omission from the cast is likely an intentional distraction by Matt Reeves to safeguard plot secrets.

The Batman
(L-r) ROBERT PATTINSON as Batman and ZOË KRAVITZ as Selina Kyle in Warner Bros. Pictures’ action adventure “THE BATMAN,” a Warner Bros. Pictures release. Photo: Jonathan Olley/™ & © DC Comics. © 2021 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. All Rights Reserved.

The Bludhaven factor—What makes it the perfect narrative sanctuary for Catwoman

At the end of Part I, Selina Kyle and Batman literally went their separate ways. The final scene showed them driving off in two totally different directions. Kyle left Gotham behind for its sister city, Blüdhaven. Blüdhaven is even more dangerous than Gotham and filled with far more corruption. Kyle went there to escape Gotham's gang wars and remain under the radar after killing Falcone. In Blüdhaven, she's less likely to be tracked by its law enforcement.

With Selina out of the picture, there's more reason for Gotham's underworld power vacuum to have room to breathe. It wouldn't be easy for the story to focus on Catwoman while also focusing on Gotham's mob war. After taking revenge on Falcone, her corrupt father, Selina's departure from Gotham felt earned. It also opened the door for her surprise return in the film's final act.

The Batman
ROBERT PATTINSON as Bruce Wayne in Warner Bros. Pictures’ action adventure “THE BATMAN,” a Warner Bros. Pictures release. Photo: Jonathan Olley/™ & © DC Comics. © 2021 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Why Batman needs Catwoman back

When Catwoman returns, she'll find Batman in a different place in his journey. Part II has to balance Batman's journey with Bruce Wayne's personal and public growth. For this to happen, Bruce's arc demands Selina Kyle's return. In Part I, Selina Kyle chose to protect herself when she left Gotham, and Batman chose to stay to protect it. He chose to be a symbol of hope, but that puts him in a difficult spot in the sequel. He will likely struggle to find himself, as he will be torn between his life as a vigilante and the billionaire philanthropist, Bruce Wayne. That's where Selina can play an important role.

The sequel could give Selina an opportunity to interact with Bruce Wayne, leading to dramatic irony because she hadn't discovered Batman's true identity in Part I. Selina and Bruce's potential chemistry, as he dons the playboy mask, creates delicious scenarios for their relationship to evolve. Pattinson and Kravitz had chemistry in Part I, but it's more fun to imagine their interactions without any masks. That could be what takes their chemistry from just good to potentially great. Could Selina target Bruce Wayne and his riches at Wayne Manor?

Keeping Zoe Kravitz's role under wraps preserves the suspense and emotional impact of her return, whenever that may be. Whether she appears in Part II or Part III, her story with Batman is far from over. After all, Batman and Catwoman are two sides of the same coin, which means keeping them apart too long isn't the best idea. Matt Reeves must have carefully planned Selina Kyle's return to Batman and Bruce Wayne's life, and it will surely mark a major turning point in his story.

Add us as a preferred source on Google